Honest comparison · Updated 2026-09-18
LoopTally vs Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting
Loopsy has built a large, genuinely well-loved following among crocheters and knitters — nearly 16,000 ratings at 4.76 stars is a real track record. LoopTally is a much narrower app built around one specific complaint: counting stitches without having to look at your phone. Here's how they compare.
Dimension-by-dimension
| Dimension | LoopTally | Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Core counting method | Volume-button counting — bump a physical button through your fabric, no looking at the screen. | On-screen tap counters, project-organized. | |
| Project & pattern management | Focused purely on counting — no pattern library or project photos. | Full project organization: patterns, notes, photos, yarn stash tracking. | |
| Row + stitch linked counting | Row and stitch counters auto-advance together as one linked flow. | Separate counters you manage yourself per project. | |
| Community features | None — it's a private counting tool. | Community patterns, project sharing, social features. | |
| Price | One-time purchase for the counting tool. | Free with in-app purchases for premium features. | |
| Maturity & reviews | New, unproven. | Nearly 16,000 ratings at 4.76 stars — an established, trusted app in the craft community. |
LoopTally advantage · Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting advantage · roughly equal
Where LoopTally wins
- Hands-free by design — the volume-button counter is built for counting without breaking eye contact with your stitches, which the app store listing's own reviewers ask for constantly in general crochet apps.
- One job, done well — no project library to set up first; open the app and start counting.
- Haptic feedback confirms every tap without needing to glance at the screen.
Where Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting wins
- A full craft companion, not just a counter — pattern storage, yarn stash, and project photos in one place if that's what you actually want.
- Established and trusted by a large, active crochet community with years of refinement behind it.
Pick LoopTally if…
You just want the fastest, most reliable way to count rows and stitches without staring at your phone mid-stitch.
See LoopTallyPick Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting if…
You want a full project-management home for your crochet and knitting — patterns, stash, and photos alongside counting.
Visit Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting siteLoopsy is the all-in-one craft companion; LoopTally is the single-purpose counter for people who just want counting to disappear into muscle memory.
Frequently asked questions
What's the main difference between LoopTally and Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting?+
Loopsy has built a large, genuinely well-loved following among crocheters and knitters — nearly 16,000 ratings at 4.76 stars is a real track record. LoopTally is a much narrower app built around one specific complaint: counting stitches without having to look at your phone. Here's how they compare.
Should I choose LoopTally or Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting?+
Pick LoopTally if: You just want the fastest, most reliable way to count rows and stitches without staring at your phone mid-stitch. Pick Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting if: You want a full project-management home for your crochet and knitting — patterns, stash, and photos alongside counting.
What can LoopTally do that Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting can't?+
Hands-free by design — the volume-button counter is built for counting without breaking eye contact with your stitches, which the app store listing's own reviewers ask for constantly in general crochet apps. One job, done well — no project library to set up first; open the app and start counting. Haptic feedback confirms every tap without needing to glance at the screen.
Where does Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting win over LoopTally?+
A full craft companion, not just a counter — pattern storage, yarn stash, and project photos in one place if that's what you actually want. Established and trusted by a large, active crochet community with years of refinement behind it.
How much does LoopTally cost compared to Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting?+
LoopTally: One-time purchase for the counting tool. Loopsy - Crochet & Knitting: Free with in-app purchases for premium features.